Roasted Garlic and Potato Salad

Roasted Garlic and Potato Salad

This potato salad is easy and makes a luxurious cold side dish, although when I decided to make it, I was a lot more concerned with the former. Because I’m lazy. Especially when I’m by myself.

John left town for a week, during which time I learned I’d been accepted into the upcoming Inman Park Festival, a bigger festival than I’ve ever done. I then spent countless hours toiling over new jewelry for the show. For company, I watched rerun after rerun of You Have Been Watching, 10 O’Clock Live, and Would I Lie to You, and by the end of the week I felt less like a delusional shut-in and more like a socially normal individual who had been hanging out with my friends Charlie and David. That was creepy of me. So I invited some friends over. Some actual friends. Who are real.

I invited them for dinner. There was time to shop, but I have a personality defect that makes it seem silly to go out if I already have something on hand that can suffice. Of course, the things I had on hand were extremely miscellaneous, because as soon as John’s plane had left the gate, I lost all sense of what time dinner was supposed to be and whether nachos counted, and it was four days before I actually prepared a meal rather than waiting until I was too hungry to cook and subsisting instead on occasional handfuls of trail mix. Trail mix wouldn’t do for a dinner party.

But I did have some potatoes to my name. Assorted potatoes. And a lemon.

I roasted a chicken breast, tossed some asparagus into the pan for the last 10 minutes, and served this roasted potato salad, which I’d made earlier in the day while tidying. After a week without supervision, the apartment had needed serious seeing to—I had literally turned every surface into a separate activity station, including the six-inch-deep railing around our patio—so in the morning, I chopped some potatoes and put them in the oven, and by the time I’d cleared the coffee table, it was time to mix up the dressing and stick the whole thing in the fridge.

It was perfect. The multitasking had made me feel like a clever cheat, but the potatoes were a hit and my friends seemed to regard dinner as somewhat fancy and special, which is important.

When John came home, he couldn’t tell I had cleaned up, which isn’t such a bad thing because restoring the apartment to Tidy Base Zero was no small feat itself, sloppy as that may still be. He helped me eat the leftover potato salad (all three bites) and I tried to think of something interesting to tell him that wasn’t about jewelry supplies or the scandalously weird cost-cutting measures proposed in Great Britain over the past couple of months (privatized motorways! granny tax! VAT on hot pasties, which doesn’t really sound like such a bad idea even if it is curiously specific!), which is to say, there’s been ample peace and quiet since his return. But I’m very glad he’s back.


Notes: I based this recipe—key aspects of it, at least—on Miss in the Kitchen’s Red Onion One Potato Two Potato Roasted Potato Salad, via Kitchen PLAY, a site with monthly menus that feature individual ingredients. The March/April ingredient sponsor is potatoes! Hooray potatoes! If potatoes ever run for public office, I should not be allowed to vote. I’m telling you now so that if it happens and you do nothing to stop it, you’ll know you’re equally to blame.

Roasted Garlic and Potato Salad

  • Roughly 2 lbs red potatoes
  • One large Idaho baking potato
  • 1/4 cup olive oil
  • Salt and pepper (black, cayenne, or both—your call)
  • One entire bulb of garlic
  • 1 Tbsp coarse mustard
  • 1 Tbsp mayonnaise
  • A squeeze of fresh lemon juice
  • Fresh chives (like… a handful. like… a dozen chives, let’s say. or substitute a Tbsp dried chives.)
  • Fresh cilantro, to taste (a few sprigs will do)
  1. Preheat oven to 400F.
  2. Scrub up your potatoes and cut them into one-inch bite-size chunks. Drizzle a couple teaspoons of olive oil over them and toss with salt and pepper. Spread them out on a shallow baking pan, lined with aluminum foil or silicone sheet for easy cleanup. Slice the top off the head of garlic, drizzle this with olive oil as well, and add to the pan with the potatoes. Roast for 25–30 minutes or until potatoes are fork-tender. Remove from oven and allow to cool.
  3. Make the dressing. In a food processor, combine remaining olive oil, mustard, mayonnaise, and lemon juice. Carefully peel roasted garlic (it’ll be mushy, but you can snap part of the peel off, clove by clove, and squeeze out the garlic) and add all of it to the dressing. Pulse until completely smooth, then add chives and cilantro and process until coarsely chopped and blended throughout. Taste the dressing and add salt, pepper, and/or more lemon juice as desired.
  4. Toss potatoes with dressing in a large bowl. Cover and chill. Serve cold.

Kristina Ackerman

Kristina Ackerman is a busy freelance web designer, living and DIYing with her fella and their little fella in a cute old house in Atlanta, GA, USA.

  • Milisa Armstrong

    Looks great, I had fun with my first Kitchen Play event.

  • http://twitter.com/rachbakes Rachel Conners

    Looks delicious! I’m not a huge fan of mayo-y potato salads so I like that this recipe uses so little of it! And who doesn’t love roasted garlic? Yum!
    -Rachel @ Bakerita.com

    • http://knucklesalad.com Kristina Ackerman

      For sure, Rachel! You can leave the mayo out altogether, if you think you’d prefer it, as in the Miss in the Kitchen recipe. I think it adds a little extra flavor and creaminess, and no one here who tried it believed me when I said there was any mayo in it at all, but I know it’d still be good without. Enjoy!

  • Myfudo

    A unique salad to grace our Easter lunch celebration… This is something i will really have to try. =)

    • http://knucklesalad.com Kristina Ackerman

      You’ll love it!

  • Tasheena

    Wow, this looks like the perfect recipe for the likes of me- I think you might be my soul mate. But the girl version, cause I’m already married and have kids with the guy version. 

    • http://knucklesalad.com Kristina Ackerman

      Hooray! A new soulmate! I wonder if we can read each other’s thoughts. You go first. Okay, ready!

  • Americanpy

    This sounds/looks yummy! So much better than the usual mayo-drenched stuff.