Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Swiss Roll Ice Cream Cake

The July 2010 Daring Bakers’ challenge was hosted by Sunita of Sunita’s world – life and food. Sunita challenged everyone to make an ice-cream filled Swiss roll that’s then used to make a bombe with hot fudge. Her recipe is based on an ice cream cake recipe from Taste of Home.

The other day, I went roller skating with some friends at a roller rink. It was called Sparkles and it had laser tag in the back and free pizza and soda for everyone with skates on, so no, if you were about to ask if it was some kind of cool 2010 roller rink full of athletic hipsters, it was not. No, just weirdos and middle schoolers, the way you remember.

It was pretty deserted.

It was fun, though. Turns out it’s easier to stay on your feet when there aren’t a bunch of zippy little kids weaving all around you at 30mph. Anyway, now I can’t remember why I started telling that story, so, uh… hey! Speaking of things that go around and around in circles, check out this ice cream cake thing covered in Swiss rolls!

Yep. Pretty much nailed that segue.

Here’s what happened. Last month, I found out about something called The Daring Kitchen, a community of people who tackle one intimidating recipe per month and then share photos and war stories. To make it more intense, they dump you if you chicken out more than four times a year. I seem to be drawn to things I can get kicked out of, so I had to apply, and this is the first recipe I was given by the Daring Bakers: a bombe with two layers of ice cream separated by chocolate sauce, covered in slices of Swiss roll.

So fancy! So delicate!

Of course, I messed mine all up. My cake rolls broke in a thousand places (so I smooshed them back together and used them anyway) and my chocolate sauce leaked out so most of it is on top of the cake instead of in the middle where it belongs. The “it may not look like much but it sure is tasty” philosophy doesn’t really apply when half the purpose of the project is to take beautiful photos, but please try to imagine the deliciousness of it into the picture. It makes the colors brighter.

Imagining will be easier once I tell you what it is! So first we’ve got chocolate sponge cake, a recipe that Sunita (the host of the challenge) provided, which is light and squishy and freezes nicely and thaws back into a very soft and fluffy cake.

That cake is rolled up with banana-infused whipped cream, which is just like regular whipped cream except I froze a banana, thawed it out, and added the liquid that was released to the whipped cream.

Then the top layer of ice cream is peanut-peanut butter frozen custard.

The chocolate sauce is one that also came from Sunita, and couldn’t have been simpler.

The bottom layer of ice cream isn’t ice cream at all, but rather frozen abused bananas.

Peanut butter, bananas, chocolate, ice cream and cake are pretty good together. (I can hear the gasps of outrage rippling across the Internet. Peanut butter! And chocolate?!) And although my little bombe won’t make it onto the cover of any magazines, I loved working on the recipe. I never would’ve tried something this complicated without encouragement, and now I feel like I could do it again if I wanted to, only better. I think this Daring Bakers thing is going to work out.

Sunita’s cake roll recipe

  • 6 medium sized eggs
  • 1 C / 225 gms caster sugar /8 oz+ extra for rolling
  • 6 tblsp / 45gms/ a pinch over 1.5 oz of all purpose (plain) flour + 5 tblsp/40gm /a pinch under 1.5 oz of natural unsweetened cocoa powder, sifted together
  • 2 tblsp /30ml / 1 fl oz of boiling water
  • a little oil for brushing the pans
  • whipped cream filling
  1. Preheat the oven at 200° C /400° F. Brush the baking pans (Sunita recommends two 11″ x 9″ pans, but I couldn’t find that size anywhere, so I made mine in one 11″ x 17″ pan and cut it down the middle after baking) with a little oil and line with greaseproof baking paper.
  2. In a large mixing bowl, add the eggs and sugar and beat till very thick; when the beaters are lifted, it should leave a trail on the surface for at least 10 seconds.
  3. Add the flour mixture in three batches and fold in gently with a spatula. Fold in the water.
  4. Divide the mixture among the two baking pans and spread it out evenly, into the corners of the pans.
  5. Place a pan in the centre of the pre heated oven and bake for about 10-12 minutes or till the centre is springy to the touch.
  6. Spread a clean kitchen towel on the counter and sprinkle caster sugar all over it.
  7. Turn the cake on to the towel and peel away the baking paper. Trim any crisp edges.
  8. Starting from one of the shorter sides, start to make a roll with the towel going inside. Cool the wrapped roll on a rack, seam side down.
  9. Repeat the same for the next cake as well.
  10. Open the rolls and spread the cream mixture, making sure it does not go right to the edges (a border of ½ an inch should be fine).
  11. Roll the cakes up again, this time without the towel. Wrap in plastic wrap and chill in the fridge till needed, seam side down.

Sunita’s hot fudge recipe

  • 1 C / 230gms/ 8 oz of caster sugar
  • 3 tblsp / 24gms/1.5 oz of natural unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 2 tblsp /15gms/ 1 oz of cornflour/cornstarch
  • 1 and ½ C /355ml /12 fl oz of water
  • 1 tblsp /14gms/ 1 oz butter
  • 1 tsp/5 ml / .15 fl oz vanilla extract
  1. In a small saucepan, whisk together the sugar, cocoa powder, cornflour and water.
  2. Place the pan over heat, and stir constantly, till it begins to thicken and is smooth (for about 2 minutes).
  3. Remove from heat and mix in the butter and vanilla. Keep aside to cool .

Basic assembly (from Taste of Home)

  1. Line a 2-qt. bowl with plastic wrap. Cut each cake roll into 1/2″ slices; place in prepared bowl, completely covering the bottom and sides. Cover and freeze for at least 20 minutes or until cake is firm.
  2. Spread vanilla ice cream over cake. Cover and freeze for at least 1 hour. Spread with fudge topping. Freeze for at least 1 hour. Spread with chocolate ice cream. Cover and freeze for up to 2 months.
  3. Just before serving, remove from the freezer and invert onto a serving plate. Remove bowl and plastic wrap. Cut into wedges.

Kristina Ackerman

Kristina Ackerman is a busy freelance web designer, living and DIYing with her fella and their little fella in a cute old house in Atlanta, GA, USA.

  • Chocolate, peanut butter and banana. Does it get much better than that??? For what it’s worth, I actually think that yours came out really nicely, and I would never guess that you had those couple little hiccups! Really awesome job on your first challenge!

  • Lovely creation! It sounds like a frozen Reeese’ Cup, lol.

    You can get Ground Wattleseed online through the sites listed here-

    Unless of course you get lucky and have an Aussie friend who can send you some.}:P

  • Great job on your first challenge! In my book you can never go wrong with peanut butter, bananas, and chocolate! You really summed up the greatness of The Daring Bakers – look forward to seeing what you come up in future challenges!

  • Welcome to the club… great start, love your choice of flavors :)

  • Well done on your first challenge! Love the flavor combination!

  • Congratulations! What an amazing effort! I had issues with the chocolate sauce, too. In the end, for all the issues I had it still tasted amazing.

  • Welcome to the Daring Bakers! You did an excellent job on your first challenge, I like that you used frozen bananas for the bottom.

  • What a beautiful bombe! I would have thought that fudge was supposed to be on top if you hadn’t told me otherwise. What a great flavor combination you chose as well. You had a great first challenge!

  • You did great on your first challenge! Judging from the pictures, it wouldn’t seem like you had those few issues. And you flavor combination sounds delicious! Great job on the challenge and welcome to the Daring Bakers’!

  • Pingback: Ravioli Party()

  • Kim

    I think your cake still looks great! You can’t even notice your swiss rolls fell apart in little pieces. And your layer of mashed bananas sound way easier than making another layer of ice cream. Nice job on the challenge!

  • Regardless of your troubles, the cake looks great. I love the sound of banana infused cream. Great job!

  • Thanks, new friends! I would offer you all a slice of ice cream cake, but I’ve eaten most of it…

  • Amazing! Bananas are a great addition. You had problems with your cake? Doesn’t show at all in the pictures.

  • Oil Pans

    Ends of “log” may be iced with a mocha icing and the log sprinkled as desired with icing sugar.

  • Lily

    Such delicious food!Let me have large appetite!It is pity that I can’t cook such good food. Obviously I don’t have such high technology.

  • Albert einstien

    shaved ice flavors
    very informative content is here, thanks for sharing such info.